We Have Seen This Before: Anti-Muslim Propaganda and the Language of the 1930s

بقلم Eric Nielson

We Have Seen This Before: Anti-Muslim Propaganda and the Language of the 1930s

I live in Casablanca, surrounded by Muslim neighbors, colleagues and friends. Lately, when I read what American and Israeli officials say about Muslims, I keep hearing an older voice underneath it. It is the voice of 1930s Germany, and of the propaganda the Nazis aimed at Jews.

I do not make that comparison lightly. But "never again" was never supposed to mean "never again for one group only." It was supposed to mean that we learn to recognize the early stages. The words always come first. So let me put the words side by side.

One Group, Blamed for Everything

Every front page of Der Stürmer, the Nazi tabloid run by Julius Streicher, carried the same slogan at the bottom: "Die Juden sind unser Unglück!" ("The Jews are our misfortune!"). The paper put the line on its pages from 1927 onward, and the paper was posted in public display cases like the one above, where anyone walking past could read it.

The genius of the slogan was its simplicity. Whatever was wrong in your life, whether unemployment, inflation or national humiliation, there was one group to blame.

In December 2015, Donald Trump's campaign called for "a total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our country's representatives can figure out what is going on." Not a particular group, not a particular threat: Muslims, nearly two billion people, treated as one problem.

Who Gets to Belong

In 1920, the Nazi Party's founding program spelled out who could belong to the nation. Point 4 reads: "Only a member of the race can be a citizen. A member of the race can only be one who is of German blood, without consideration of confession. Consequently, no Jew can be a member of the race." In 1935, that idea became law through the Reich Citizenship Law, one of the Nuremberg Laws.

In March 2026, Representative Andy Ogles of Tennessee posted that "Muslims don't belong in American society." He did not back down when his colleagues objected. He had already called Zohran Mamdani, now the elected mayor of New York, "little Muhammad" and demanded that he be deported. Representative Randy Fine of Florida called Mamdani "little more than a Muslim terrorist" and also said he should be deported.

Mamdani is an American citizen. When elected officials start talking about deporting citizens because of their religion, they are making the same argument the Nazi program made in 1920: that a person's faith or origin decides whether they truly belong.

Less Than Human

The 1940 Nazi film Der ewige Jude ("The Eternal Jew") contains one of the most notorious sequences in the history of propaganda. As the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum describes it, the film compares the movement of Jews across the world to the mass migrations of rats, cutting to footage of rats swarming out of a drain and through sacks of grain. Audiences were not meant to argue with the comparison. They were meant to feel disgust. The film was shown to soldiers, police and SS units.

On October 9, 2023, Israel's defense minister, Yoav Gallant, announced a complete siege of Gaza: "No electricity, no food, no water, no fuel. Everything is closed. We are fighting human animals, and we act accordingly." In February 2026, Randy Fine posted that the choice between dogs and Muslims was not a difficult one, and then wrote: "We need more Islamophobia, not less."

Dehumanizing language is not a side effect. It is the point. People who would never harm a neighbor can be persuaded to accept almost anything done to "animals."

Laughing at the Drowning

In March 1938, after Germany annexed Austria, Jews in Vienna were dragged into the streets and forced to scrub the pavements on their hands and knees while crowds gathered to watch and laugh. Humiliation was entertainment. It taught onlookers that these people's suffering was not just acceptable but funny.

This month, the first winter storm flooded around 70,000 tents in Gaza, where most of the population has been displaced since the genocide began in 2023. Five people were killed, four of them children. Tents and shelter kits were reported to be sitting at the border, waiting for Israeli authorities to let them in. And online, I have watched people respond to footage of families wading through flooded camps with jokes about "from the river to the sea," laughing at the idea that the slogan had finally come true.

When the drowning of children becomes a punchline, something has already been decided about whether those children count as human.

The Enemy Within

Nazi propaganda did not only say Jews were inferior. It said they were dangerous: secretly organized, loyal to a foreign conspiracy, working to destroy the nation from inside. The sign over the display case above says it plainly: "This is the Jew: the enemy of all nations." That was the purpose of the "Judeo-Bolshevism" myth, which cast Jews as the hidden hand behind communism. It fused a religious minority with a political enemy, so that hating one meant fearing the other.

Today that fusion is back, almost word for word. "Islamo-communist" and "Islamo-Marxist" have become stock insults for Muslims on the left, above all New York's mayor, Zohran Mamdani. In April 2026, Representative Chip Roy of Texas introduced a bill called the MAMDANI Act, short for "Measures Against Marxism's Dangerous Adherents and Noxious Islamists." It would bar, denaturalize and deport members of socialist, communist and "Islamic fundamentalist" groups. France ran its own version in 2021, when its higher education minister claimed that "Islamo-leftism" was eating away at society and ordered an investigation into the country's universities. France's national research agency, the CNRS, answered that the term corresponds to no scientific reality. Neither did "Judeo-Bolshevism."

The modern version is the claim that any Muslim in public life is secretly an agent of something. At a rally in Port Huron, Michigan, in October 2026, Trump called Abdul El-Sayed, a doctor and the Democratic Senate nominee, a "jihadist" and a member of the Muslim Brotherhood, and suggested he should have to pass through a metal detector to enter the Senate. There is no evidence for any of it. El-Sayed won anyway, and became the first Muslim elected to the Senate.

The fear is also being cultivated on purpose. In 2025, Drop Site News reported on a leaked study commissioned by Israel's Foreign Ministry from the marketing firm Stagwell. It found that defending Israel's conduct in Gaza did little to win over Western audiences, while warning them about "radical Islam" was among the most effective messages tested.

Words Come First

On January 30, 1939, Hitler told the Reichstag: "If the international Jewish financiers in and outside Europe should succeed in plunging the nations once more into a world war, then the result will not be the Bolshevization of the earth, and thus the victory of Jewry, but the annihilation of the Jewish race in Europe!" Many people at the time dismissed it as rhetoric. It was not.

That is the lesson I keep coming back to. The slogans, the citizenship rules and the rat footage all came before the death camps. Each step made the next one easier to accept.

In Gaza, the distance between words and actions has already closed. In January 2024, the International Court of Justice found that Palestinians in Gaza had plausible rights to protection under the Genocide Convention and ordered Israel to prevent and punish incitement to genocide. In September 2025, the UN's Independent International Commission of Inquiry concluded that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, and that top Israeli officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, incited it. The defense minister who spoke of "human animals" then cut off food, water and fuel to more than two million people. The dehumanizing language did exactly what it has always done: it made the unthinkable feel acceptable.

What Remembering Requires

The people who lived through the 1930s did not have the benefit of hindsight. We do. We know what this kind of language is for, and we know where it can lead. Remembering the Holocaust honestly means refusing to accept the same playbook when it is turned on someone else.

The anti-Muslim rhetoric in American politics and the genocide in Gaza are not separate stories. The same language that tells Americans their Muslim neighbors do not belong tells the world that Palestinian lives do not count, and it is used to sell the bombs, the siege and the silence.

My neighbors here in Casablanca are not a problem to be solved, a threat to be contained or animals to be caged. Neither are the people of Gaza. Neither were the Jews of Europe. The people who use this language today are counting on us not to recognize it. We should prove them wrong.


Eric Nielson is the founder of Nielson English and an editor and translator at TelQuel English.